18 Nov 2026

IM BLOG: We need better records management. No. You need a performance conversation.

Is better records management really the answer, or is it time for a performance conversation? This IM Blog challenges the idea that more policies, systems and processes will fix information management issues, exploring why accountability, workplace behaviours and leadership may be the real keys to improvement.

Peta Sweeney - We need better records management..png

I’ve had this exchange too many times lately.

Consider a familiar scenario. A staff member needs to share a secured document with a colleague who does not currently have access to it in the eDRMS. They know the correct approach is to update the permissions or follow the approved process for having them updated so the colleague can work from the governed source.

Instead, they download the document and email it because that is easier.

The employee knows what to do. They know how to do it. They have been trained. They still choose the shortcut.

When this comes to light, the conversation is usually: How do we fix records management? Do we need more training, another reminder or a stronger system control?

Wrong question.

If the permissions process is accessible, reasonable and timely, the real question is: Why is this not being managed as a potential performance issue?

Before you call it a performance issue

Not every failure to follow a records process is a performance problem. Before reaching that conclusion, you need to establish that the employee genuinely could comply.

Ask:

  • Was the expectation clearly communicated?
  • Has appropriate training been provided?
  • Can the employee access and use the required system?
  • Do they understand what must be captured or protected—and why?
  • Is the approved process reasonable within the way the work is performed?
  • Are workload, conflicting instructions or competing priorities getting in the way?

In our example, changing permissions may be so slow or complicated that emailing the document has become the only practical way to keep the work moving. If that is the case, the organisation has a process or system problem to solve.

It may instead uncover unclear guidance, inadequate training, poor technology, a capability gap or conflicting managerial expectations. Records and information management practitioners should absolutely help identify and remove those barriers.

But if the expectation is reasonable, understood and achievable and someone repeatedly chooses not to meet it, the problem has shifted. It is no longer simply evidence that the records management program needs improvement. It may be evidence that an employee is not meeting an established requirement of their role.

Where responsibility shifts

Good recordkeeping is not an administrative favour performed for the records team. It is part of doing the work properly.

Staff create and receive information while making decisions, approving expenditure, delivering services, managing risk and exercising authority. Capturing, protecting and managing the evidence of those activities is part of the activity itself, not a separate task to complete if time permits.

The records team’s role is to establish workable controls, provide clear guidance, build capability, monitor outcomes and identify risk. It cannot supervise every staff member’s daily behaviour. Nor should it be expected to compensate indefinitely when managers do not reinforce agreed requirements.

This does not mean the first managerial response should be punitive. A performance conversation can begin with curiosity:

What prevented you from following the process? Was something unclear? Was the approved option impractical? Was another priority or instruction getting in the way?

That conversation may reveal a genuine barrier. If it does, the organisation should fix it.

If no barrier exists, the manager should clarify the expectation, agree on what must change and follow up. Continued failure can then be addressed through the organisation’s usual performance processes, with appropriate HR guidance where necessary.

For records and information management practitioners prompting this shift is not always easy. The relevant manager may be more senior. The organisational culture may treat recordkeeping as the records team’s problem. Raising repeated non-compliance may be interpreted as criticism rather than risk management.

But referring the issue to management is not admitting defeat or surrendering professional agency. Our role is to make the pattern visible: identify the control failure, document the support already provided, explain the consequences and report the risk through the appropriate governance channels.

Management must then manage.

Stop redesigning around avoidable behaviour

Treating every instance of non-compliance as a records management failure creates a costly cycle.

The records team redesigns the process, repeats the training and produces more guidance. Staff learn that requirements can be ignored because the response will be another organisation-wide awareness campaign rather than an individual conversation. Managers remain removed from the issue, while unmanaged information continues to create risks for security, privacy, accountability, access, decision-making and organisational memory.

There is also an opportunity cost. Time spent retraining people who already know what to do is time not spent on genuinely difficult work: governing emerging platforms, managing high-risk information, enabling defensible disposal, supporting AI readiness or addressing systemic control gaps.

Better records management does not always require another policy, system or training session. If people cannot comply, fix the environment. If they do not understand, build their capability. If the process is unreasonable, redesign it. But when people know what is expected, have the tools and capability to meet that expectation and repeatedly choose not to do so, stop asking the records team to solve it.

Have the performance conversation.

Meet your blog author:

Peta Sweeney.png

 

Peta Sweeney CXRIM FRIM (Life), Information and Content Specialist, RIMPA Global